🎉 Up to 70% Off Selected ItemsShop Sale

Home Shop Cart Account

Store

Cakes and Pies

Subscribe to our newsletter for exclusive offers, new arrivals, and style inspiration.

Shop

All Products
New Arrivals
Sale

Company

Shipping Info
FAQ
Contact Us

About

About Us
Returns
Privacy

© 2026 The Old Mill. All rights reserved.

Cakes and Pies | The Old Mill

Moonshine Cake

$17.99

Old Forge Moonshine Cake Combo

$39.99

French Toast Moonshine Cake

$17.99

The Pottery House Cafe Chocolate Pecan Pie

$39.99

The Old Mill Restaurant Pecan Pie

$39.99

Signature Pound Cake

$34.99

-65%

Old Forge Coconut Rum Cake

$49.99

$17.50

-65%

Cranberry Orange Cornmeal Cake

$44.99

$15.75

-65%

Southern Peach And Honey Baking Kit

$38.99

$13.65